Sunday, October 16, 2016

Bob Dylan and the 2016 Nobel Prize for Literature: The Times are a-Changin'?

I don't think we can be surprised by Americans' strong reactions to the recent selection of Bob Dylan as the Nobel Laureate in Literature

On the one hand there is loud applause, some of it well-considered. In Rolling Stone, Rob Sheffield alludes to Emerson's 1850 essay, "Shakespeare; or the Poet," in which Emerson notes that the great that Shakespeare played to the groundlings and moved on, unconcerned with the durability of any particular work or even if it was recorded. Likewise, he thinks, Dylan's ability to keep moving forward, never stuck on past successes, is a laudable strength. Like the Nobel committee, Sheffield is happy to place Dylan in the long literary tradition of bards. 

On the other hand, Anna North writes in The New York Times,"As reading declines around the world, literary prizes are more important than ever. A big prize means a jump in sales and readership even for a well-known writer." She further points out that music has plenty of awards, and Dylan has already been an acclaimed presence in his field: "Literature needs a Nobel Prize." Literature is books, and Dylan ain't books.

For my own part, I could do very well without the Nobel Prize or any other literary prize. 

What do they do? What do they celebrate? How do they edify us? Prizes are awarded to people who are already well known and oft-honored their accomplishments. Despite carefully organized, byzantine review processes, really nothing is easier than awarding conspicuous success. 

At the top of the literary judging game, what really distinguishes one famous nominee from another? Number of books sold? Number of good reviews? Reviews by whom and placed where? Honors by what organizations? How many translations? Dollars spent by their publisher's marketing department? Market penetration?

For many awards, the judges will be peers who have been nominated for similar awards and who in fact hold them. They are likely to move in the same circles, know one another professionally, have mingled at the same international conferences, spoken on the same panels, and often been competition for the same honors.

In the days when I socialized with honored scientists, they pointed out that the best predictor for winning a science Nobel was the number of Laureates one knew. 

But, people argue, Bob Dylan isn't like that! He's not part of the academic establishment! He's from a different world, fresh and unsullied! The times, they are a-changin'!

The nomination process for the Swedish Academy is long and careful, insuring that the five finalists will indeed be the best of the best in the terms set and honored since 1901. The longevity and tradition of the Prizes is what gives them their meaning and revered status, after all.

The nominators are not chosen from the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. They are chosen from the heads of eminent literary societies, previous Nobel winners, national academies of high cultural purpose, and honored professors of literature. 

People in the position to nominate for Nobel Prizes have exalted positions not merely because they are smart or learned. Professors gain high positions by virtue of their scholarship, but also by their aptitude for academic politics, which allows them to win the competitions at every level of an extremely hierarchical profession; to become the heads of those learned societies or cultural organizations that sponsor their own prizes.

Many wish to assume that the election of Bob Dylan means the Swedish Academy is loosening up, becoming more generous with its definition of literature, and more in tune with the poetry of the groundlings. By its explicit admission, the Academy is emphatically not sending a populist message. Listen to the official announcement by Sarah Danius  and her question and answer session.

Professor Danius tells us that conferring the prize has nothing to do with Bob Dylan's popular culture status. The importance is his link to the ancient Greek tradition of oral poetry. 

Thus, the Swedish Academy has defined Dylan squarely into traditional, vaunted, academic norms: the very norms that we ourselves worship their prizes for maintainingeven those of us who praise their choice because we wish to honor a folk-rock hero. 

Who would care about the Nobels if they weren't considered the creme de la creme, the most prestigious of all, the tops? The Nobel must be the most exclusive: It is crucial to all of us.

If the Nobels were not this way, why would there be such strong opinions about whether Dylan is deserving or not? 

If we really believed that the Academy were diluting the prestige of its award by honoring a body of popular art, it would be the beginning of the end of our interest in the Prize. We depend on our perceived authority of the Nobel Prize. We need it to be arbiter of the Best because without it, we are left to our own standards, and that's not very comforting.

Even knowing that the Nobel "best" comes from a system defined by the least changeable, most entrenched cultural standards, we'll keep it and honor it.

Who's the real winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature? The Swedish Academy, every year. We, the public, are the runners-up, since we depend utterly on the Academy's authority to reassure us that Best exists in literature. 

We love the idea that Standards exist and that an Academy will decide on the standards, even when the Academy's choice redefines the artist most of us know as the person whose voice led the counter culture for years. 

Finally! Dylan has the seal of approval that the grown-ups withheld when he meant the most to the most people. Now he has the very Nobel Prize itself!

The Committee chose whom they wished to choose, by what criteria they wished, against competition we will never know. One thing is sure: They did not choose the folk-rock hero of a generation. They chose an artist whom they deem ready for canonization. 

That's what the Nobel Prizes are for.To ease artists into the canon. To defang what once was fierce; to mainstream what made us dream or change our ways. To enter into the professors' curricula as approved content what once broke hearts and made a really big difference—art that felt like it was ours alone. Art that now can be explained.

That's what literary prizes are for in general: to tame with rewards and to affirm the authority and standing of the granting organization. Without their wisdom, what would we ever figure out? What would we know about literature, on our own, unguided and without category?

14 comments:

  1. Again Starr Review has lead us through the aesthetic thicket. Brava!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dating for everyone is here: ❤❤❤ Link 1 ❤❤❤


      Direct sexchat: ❤❤❤ Link 2 ❤❤❤

      QT .

      Delete
  2. Nice, Ann Starr. I wish my parents were alive to see this award granted. And earned. Not to shove it in their faces to show them who was right--us or them. They changed with the times, too, and I think they would have appreciated Bob Dylan with his Nobel Prize

    ReplyDelete
  3. I approve. I believe it to be well-earned. My father would have liked this, and he was an incredibly thoughtful and knowledgeable scholar and musician. Wondering though, about the competition? Thanks Ann!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your article has really peaked my interest. I will bookmark your blog and keep checking for new information about once per week. Thank You... :)
    Filmi Keeda Review

    ReplyDelete
  5. My brother recommended I might like this web site. He was totally right. This put up actually made my day. You can not believe just how much time I had spent for this information! Thank you! JPR Hosting

    ReplyDelete
  6. Awesome article, it was exceptionally helpful! I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome!

    Okinawa Flat Belly Tonic

    BioFit Probiotic

    ReplyDelete
  7. My brother recommended, I might like this web site. He was totally right. This put up actually made my day. You can not believe just how much time I had spent for this information! Thank you for sharing I believe a lot of people will be surprised to read this article. This article provides light by which we can notice the reality. This really is very nice one and allows advanced information. Get It SMS is a India No 1 bulk SMS Service provider. We are giving special offer in bulk SMS service. Our Services are Voice SMS, promotional bulk SMS, transactional SMS, miss call service, bulk e-mailing, transactional bulk SMS, Missed call alert Whatsapp SMS and website Design. Sign Up for a free trial!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, I Read your blog and I feel it is a very wonderful, informative blog . There are a lot of good information on this blog, I'd like to Share and I think people will get a lot of support from this blog. Thank you for sharing this informative blog, please keep up and share some unique posts with us in the future.
    Blockchain Technology

    ReplyDelete
  9. Maintaining industrial cooling towers isn’t an easy task if you don’t know much about them.
    With a little knowledge, you can make this task simple and efficient for yourself. By proper maintenance, you can enhance the performance and longevity of your chiller as well.
    Just follow these tips to maintain your industrial chiller:
    Regular Inspection
    The fundamental method to maintain your industrial cooling tower is to inspect it regularly. From the gearbox to the water pump, you should do regular inspection to ensure there are no loose components.
    Regular inspection will also allow you to spot corrosion, scaling and other similar adverse issues.
    When you’ll find these issues before they escalate, you can get rid of them and keep your chiller in optimum condition.

    Maintaining industrial cooling towers isn’t an easy task if you don’t know much about them.
    With a little knowledge, you can make this task simple and efficient for yourself. By proper maintenance, you can enhance the performance and longevity of your chiller as well.
    Just follow these tips to maintain your industrial chiller:
    Regular Inspection
    The fundamental method to maintain your industrial cooling tower is to inspect it regularly. From the gearbox to the water pump, you should do regular inspection to ensure there are no loose components.
    Regular inspection will also allow you to spot corrosion, scaling and other similar adverse issues.
    When you’ll find these issues before they escalate, you can get rid of them and keep your chiller in optimum condition.
    Removing Deposits of Impurities
    Impurities present in the water of the cooling tower gets collected in the system. They hinder the temperature of the chiller. Impure water requires more energy for changing its temperature.
    So if you don’t use a cleaning system for your cooling tower, it’s necessary that you clean the tubes regularly and check the chiller for any sedimentation.
    The collected impurities can damage the life of your chiller too. So you should remove those deposits regularly for keeping the tower free from any issues.

    Read More: Importance of inspiring leadership in the HVAC industry by Tsur Ben David

    ReplyDelete
  10. Tsur Ben David
    Founder and acting CEO

    CET Enviro was founded by Tsur Ben David, a former Air Force pilot and serial entrepreneur in the field of cleantech. With over 27 years of management experience in the energy and water industries, and leading development and global projects in cleantech, technology and product companies, Tsur Ben David is instrumental in bringing goal-oriented and pragmatic approach, and an uncompromising urge to deliver quality results.

    Tsur Ben David, who has an extensive experience in local and international business development, specializes in identifying and developing commercial relationships in potential international markets, and recruiting strategic partners. He is known in the field as a creative and committed professional with diverse experience in managing international businesses, channel development, technologies and markets.

    The company and its employees all support the CEO's vision of combining business values with values to contribute to the preservation of the planet by keeping global water sources free of pollutants and preventing the waste of energy that releases pollutants into the atmosphere.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Do you want to start a business or looking for a startup? Are you looking for a WhatsApp reseller panel to start your business? You have come to the right place to have the service of the WhatsApp reseller panel. GetItSMS is providing the services of a WhatsApp Reseller Panel to help entrepreneurs. With this service, they can start a new business as the world is choosing the best bulk SMS service for their businesses. WhatsApp bulk SMS service has become one of the top services after marketing a business in the market. If you are looking for a WhatsApp reseller service provider in India or in any part of the country. We will provide you with the best service to start your business in India.

    Jaipur the city of heritages! The city is also called Pink City, being one of the most popular tourist’s attractions all over the world has created opportunities for all types of businesses in Jaipur. Whether they are travel agencies, hotels or services of tourist guides, Bulk SMS in Jaipur can help them to approach all those customers that need them. Cities like Jaipur are hubs for all types of businesses small or large so all companies want to promote their services. Promoting your service through multimedia may be expensive for your business even though all these need an audience to see your still or motion advertising. If your targeted audience doesn’t come to all these platforms your time and money will be wasted and this is a big worry for you!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dating for everyone is here: ❤❤❤ Link 1 ❤❤❤


    Direct sexchat: ❤❤❤ Link 2 ❤❤❤

    xb...

    ReplyDelete